
Since the 1950’s, San Francisco has undergone dramatic changes to its physical landscape and seen the economic demographics of its population shaped by political decisions regarding urban development. SPUR, the San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association, is offering a thought-provoking exhibit on San Francisco’s urban history at its recently completed new building at 654 Mission Street. Titled, “Agents of Change: Civic Idealism & The Making of San Francisco,” the exhibit includes rarely seen documents used to justify the city-funded massive displacement of low-income people from the South of Market and Fillmore. It also covers the fight against Mission gentrification and the evictions at the International Hotel. But the exhibit ignores key activist successes that have prevented San Francisco from becoming an exclusively rich colony like Manhattan. For example, it completely excludes the Tenderloin from San Francisco’s urban history, probably because the community prevailed against the massive development interests that the exhibit otherwise implies were unstoppable.
SPUR’s exhibit includes photos, newsletters, maps and a diverse range of historic memorabilia charting San Francisco’s development into a major urban center over the past eighty years. Policy wonks will want to visit the exhibit multiple times, but the exhibit is designed so that those with little knowledge of the city’s development can quickly get up to speed.
Development and Displacement
While the exhibit discusses how San Francisco’s growth addressed design and environmental issues, and the city’s role in protecting the Bay, the dominant theme is the relationship between how the city’s development strategy was based upon, and some would say dictated by, the removal of low-income people and African-Americans from entire communities.
While Chester Hartman’s classic “Yerba Buena Land Grab” long ago exposed the Redevelopment Agency’s development/displacement strategy for SOMA, many San Franciscans do not know this story and will find SPUR’s exhibit in this area an eye-opener. The same is true for the Agency’s displacement of African-Americans from the Fillmore and Western Addition, with SPUR providing some great photos used to justify this monumental blight on the city’s history.
The documents and photos show that housing and other structures were rundown in both neighborhoods, and that government spending to improve conditions was necessary. But the Agency’s primary goal in both communities was to displace existing residents with more upscale consumers, with the Fillmore’s location far from downtown making its demolition almost entirely racially -based.
For those familiar with the history of these two neighborhoods, and with the frequently chronicled struggle at the I-Hotel, the exhibit’s analysis is not new but the photos and documents are fun to see. The less told story of the rise of Mission District activism in the 1960’s is also included, though its connection to current struggles in the community is left unclear (longtime organizer Mike Miller has an upcoming book on 1960’s Mission activism that might address this).
For all its policy wonkish talk about “planning” and “design,” the exhibit’s dominant theme is the triumph of San Francisco development interests over the needs of working people. And where San Francisco’s history went in a different direction – as in the Tenderloin community – well, this history is excluded entirely.
Activists Often Win
The curator’s exclusion of the city’s only low-income neighborhood that successfully defeated development interests is curious. He was either too focused on covering the negative impacts of development on the poor in SOMA, Fillmore, the I-Hotel, and, to a lesser extent, the Mission, or simply did not spend any time learning the Tenderloin’s history.
Having worked in the Tenderloin for nearly thirty years, I am obviously proud of our community’s success preserving its low-income character. I know that in the early 1980’s, everyone – and I mean everyone – assumed would fall prey to massive touristification and gentrification.
But as I discuss in The Activist’s Handbook, the accomplishments of Tenderloin activists have changed the course of urban development not only in San Francisco, but nationally. The Tenderloin was the first community to require big developers to pay for affordable housing as a condition of development, a policy described as a milestone when later called “linkage” and enacted by Boston’s Mayor Ray Flynn.
It was attempted tourist hotel conversions in the Tenderloin that led to the passage of the nation’s first SRO anti-conversion and demolition law. Similar measures were since adopted in other cities, but the SPUR exhibit might have noted that the inability of developers to demolish an SRO became a deterrent to upscale development on the site of such housing.
Similarly, Tenderloin activists won a strict downzoning of the community in 1985. This imposed sharp restrictions on height and non-residential development that would have made the post dot-com battles in the Mission and SOMA unnecessary had these community’s enacted similar measures.
Activist’ success meant the Tenderloin did not have the type of development that the SPUR exhibit chronicles. But its important that people not leave an exhibit of this type feeling that big money always wins, or that developers have had free reign to chart San Francisco’s future.
This being said, anyone who cares about San Francisco development or who has ever attended a Planning Commission meeting should be sure to visit the exhibit (which is free!). It runs until November 15 in SPUR’s beautiful new headquarters, which has been designed to create the type of urban dialogue that can only help San Francisco make better planning decisions in the future.
Randy Shaw is Editor of Beyond Chron. For more information on the exhibit, go to www.spur.org